IMSLP Forums

I have noticed that occasionally, new scores of existing works appear here. An example is #28951, a score of Haydn's symphony Hob I:96, sometimes known as 'The Miracle' (although the report about a crashing chandelier should actually be associated with Hob I:102). The score in question, by the CCARH...

There are now two copies of these six symphonies available here. Only one of them, the symphony in A minor, is definitely by Vanhal (it is Bryan a2). The second symphony in Eb has three movements, and the second and third are identical to those of Rosetti's symphony KI-5, A23 (that symphony is avail...

Hi Tim,

That's very helpful information - thank you!

I would be grateful if anyone has any ideas on the real authorship of the Op. 23 and Op. 25 symphonies attributed here to Vanhal. Grove dismisses all of Op.25 as 'non-authentic', and says that only Op. 23/4 of the earlier set is genuine Vanhal (it is genuine, it's the symphony a2, published as the s...