3 Sonatinas, Op.38 (Clementi, Muzio)

[Davydov]

Can someone take a look at this and say whether or not it's actually by Clementi? According to Grove his Op.38 should be a set of 12 waltzes for percusssion (!), and the keys of the three sonatinas in the uploaded set don't match any of the sets in Clementi's worklist. There's also a logo on the edition that should perhaps be removed.

[kalliwoda]

The logo on these files is the logo of the uplader, Caprotti. So this should be fine - there was even a discussion on the forum here some weeks ago viewtopic.php?f=3&t=2819&hilit=caprotti

There are several other editions of Sonatinas op.38 on the italian internet culturale:
http://opac.internetculturale.it/cgi-bi ... ate=musica
so this should be just a case of duplicated opus numbers

Edit: In worldcat there is an 1820's André entry: "6 leichte Sonatinen, op. 36 (früher op. 38)"

[ctesibius]

Hi, the thematic catalog of Alan Tyson say op. 38 12 Waltzer for piano triangle and percussion. also transcribed for piano and flute
The same the new critical edition
http://www.muzioclementi.com/critica.php?l=ing

Ctesibius

----
II. CHAMBER MUSIC
1. Works for Ensembles of 3 to 9 Instruments
III 12 Waltzes for Piano with Tambourine and Triangle Accompaniment Op. 38
12 Waltzes for Piano with Tambourine and Triangle Accompaniment Op. 39
Canone finito a tre for 2 Violins e Viola Op-sn 26 (WO 29)
Nonet for Fl, Ob, Cl, Fg, Cr, Vl, Vla, Vc, Cb Op-sn 28-29 (WO 30-31)
-----

[Davydov]

Thanks, ctesibius. Is there anything in the thematic catalog that would match the works we have as Op.38? Perhaps the work has been wrongly attributed to Clementi...

[ctesibius]

Hi,
the correct opus number is op. 4 nos. 4-6
Six sonatas for piano with violin or flute op. 4

in particular
op. 4 no. 4 = op. 38 no. 1
op. 4 no. 5 = op. 38 no. 2
op. 4 no. 6 = op. 38 no. 3


"http://www.mediafire.com/file/yet2zdnzyum/muzio clementi. thematic catalog. op.4.pdf"
"http://www.mediafire.com/file/vnm12mzkdy4/muzio clementi. thematic catalog. op.38.pdf"

Ctesibius

[Davydov]

Thanks Ctesibius! The same files were actually included on the Op.4 page as well, and as the Op.38 reference appears to be spurious I've just redirected Op.38 to Op.4.

[Caprotti]

When I uploaded a lot of Clementi's scores I was very careful to follow Tyson's thematic catalogue. I'm not responsible for further wrong address links that were made by IMSLP administrators !